22 november 2007
Michael Robertson is weer eens aangeklaagd: nu door EMI, vanwege blijkbare inbreuken op het copyright met zijn muziekdienst MP3Tunes. EMI is het eerste label dat MP3 zonder DRM-techniek aanbiedt en de vroegere Chief Executive Officer Eric Nicoli zei bij de lancering daarvan: 'We're delighted that this amazing band's songs can now be purchased directly from their website in a format that can be enjoyed on all music players'. Nicoli trad in augustus terug na de overname door Terra Firma en blijkbaar zijn voor het nieuwe management 'all music players' geen 'devices that play music from an online storage locker, or music search engines'. Deze zijn normaal gesproken beschermd voor de Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Robertson ziet een groot probleem: de muziekindustrie wil blijkbaar nu zoekmachines aanpakken. 'EMI's lawsuit complains both about Sideload.com and the personal Music Lockers offered by MP3tunes. Sideload is an audio search engine. It has links to audio files and shows you where those files are on the net. Sideload does not host any files. There are many, many such search engines. Here are just a few, with the same starting letter "S" as Sideload: Songza, Seeqpod, and Skreemr – all of which are probably much bigger than Sideload. Many people simply use Google, which is likely the biggest audio search engine in the world. Any complaint against Sideload could be leveled against Google, Yahoo, MSN, and Ask since they all have links to song files'.